<!DOCTYPE HTML PUBLIC "-//IETF//DTD HTML//EN">


<HTML>
    <HEAD>
        <LINK REV=OWNER HREF="mailto:jsacco@gmu.edu (John Sacco)">
        <TITLE>
            Types of Funds (presentation)
        </TITLE>
    </HEAD>
    <BODY BGCOLOR="#FFFFFF" TEXT="#000000">

        <CENTER>

        <H1>
            Types of Funds
        </H1>

        <A HREF="C3S3-index.html">
            Lesson three
        </A>
        presentation, from
        <A HREF="C3-index.html">
            chapter III
        </A>
        of
        <A HREF="index.html">
            <CITE>
                Financial Reporting in Government
            </CITE>
        </A>
        <BR>

        By
        <A HREF="http://mason.gmu.edu/~jsacco">
            Dr.  John Sacco
        </A>
,        <A HREF="http://www.gmu.edu">
            George Mason University
        </A>
        <BR>

        Revised <B>
<!--#config timefmt="%A, %B %d, %Y"-->
<!--#echo var="LAST_MODIFIED"-->
        </B>

        </CENTER>

        <HR NOSHADE WIDTH="85%">
        <DL>
            <DT>
                <H2>
                    Reform Origin of Funds
                </H2>
            </DT>
            <DD>
                Thus far the discussion has been about the different
                <A HREF="C3S2-index.html">
                    financial statements
                </A>
                without any detailed discussion of the
                <A HREF="C3-glossary.html#defn:funds">
                    funds
                </A>
                that go into the statements.  Recall that funds are used
                to make sure that money designated for a specific
                purpose by the legislature is raised and spent for that
                purpose and only that purpose.  As noted, this concern
                about adhering to legislative mandates is a carry over
                from the reformers of the turn of the 20th century.
                That reform followed on the heals of the corruption of
                the spoils system and tried to correct it, often with
                detailed rules.  Funds were part of these detailed
                rules.
                <P>
                    In actuality, each financial statement is for a
                    fund.  If a government has a 150 funds, there are
                    potentially 150
                    <A
                        HREF="C3-glossary.html#defn:statement%20of%20revenues,%20expenditures,%20and%20changes%20in%20fund%20balance">
                        statements of revenues, expenditures, and
                        changes in fund balance
                    </A>
                    for each of these funds.  The same goes for the
                    <A HREF="C3-glossary.html#defn:balance%20sheet">
                        balance sheet
                    </A>
.                    The names of the statements can change depending on
                    the type of funds, but it is the number of funds
                    that drives the number of statements that a
                    government must keep.  In the
                    <A HREF="C1S2-index.html">
                        CARF
                    </A>
,                    presentation is at very high
                    <A
                        HREF="C3-glossary.html#defn:level%20of%20aggregation%20within%20funds">
                        level of aggregation
                    </A>
,                    but even this aggregated presentation is driven by
                    funds.  For example, all the capital project funds
                    and special revenue funds will be aggregated but the
                    presentation will still be by funds.
                </P>
            </DD>
            <DT>
                <H2>
                    The Reinventing Critiques of Funds
                </H2>
            </DT>
            <DD>
                More recent discussion of government performance from
                those interested in
                <A
                    HREF="C3-glossary.html#defn:reinventing%20government">
                    reinventing government
                </A>
                has been critical of the minutiae that has crept into
                government in general and financial reporting in
                particular.  Funds are perceived as part of government's
                heavy rule laden operations. Funds can be so numerous
                and detailed that the general reader of financial
                reports gets lost and is unable to determine whether
                mandates are being carried out and whether the
                jurisdiction as a whole performed well.  However, the
                chief official recognition of this problem from GASB and
                its predecessors was to admonish government to keep the
                number of funds to a minimum, not to do away with funds.
                Funds remain a center piece of financial reporting.
            </DD>
            <DT>
                <H2>
                    Basic Type of Funds
                </H2>
                <DL>
                        There are three basic types of funds and many
                        subtypes within the basic types.  A list of the
                        three main types--governmental, proprietary, and
                        fiduciary--and subtypes is given below:

                        <DL>

                            <DT>
                                Governmental Funds

                            </DT>
                            <DD>
                                <MENU>
                                    <LI>
                                        general
                                    </LI>
                                    <LI>
                                        special revenue
                                    </LI>
                                    <LI>
                                        capital project
                                    </LI>
                                    <LI>
                                        debt service
                                    </LI>
                                </MENU>

                            </DD>
                            <DT>
                                Proprietary

                            </DT>
                            <DD>
                                <MENU>
                                    <LI>
                                        internal service
                                    </LI>
                                    <LI>
                                        enterprise
                                    </LI>
                                </MENU>

                            </DD>
                            <DT>
                                Fiduciary

                            </DT>
                            <DD>
                                <MENU>
                                    <LI>
                                        trust
                                    </LI>
                                    <LI>
                                        agency
                                    </LI>
                                </MENU>

                            </DD>
                        </DL>

                        It is possible for a single statement, such as
                        the statement of revenues, expenditures and
                        changes in fund balance, to have all these fund
                        types.  Furthermore, within a subfund like
                        special revenue there many be many individual
                        special revenue funds.
                    <DT>
                        <H2>
                            Government Funds
                        </H2>
                    </DT>
                    <DD>
                        Government funds are really directed to current
                        activities and often to the annual budget.
                        Budgets work on the premise of money coming in
                        for the year and money going out for the same
                        period.  The government funds frequently follow
                        the budget logic and always follow the logic of
                        examining transactions and events of the current
                        period or shortly thereafter.
                        <P>
                            The government funds are the most common and
                            within the government funds, the general
                            fund is always present.  The general fund
                            accounts for typical, day to day activities
                            of government such as safety, recreation,
                            and planning.  The other funds have more
                            specific roles.  Special revenue funds are
                            for activities the legislature wishes to
                            track via a specific fund. Activities
                            related to schools, highways, and parks are
                            often placed into special revenue funds.
                            Capital project funds are designed to track
                            the money and spending for major physical
                            projects, such as buildings.  However,
                            purchase or construction of assets with a
                            life greater than a year can be placed in a
                            capital project fund.  As a result, the
                            capital project fund is an area open to
                            possible abuse.  Uniforms, vehicles parts,
                            and even supplies have been placed in
                            capital project funds to permit paying for
                            these not with revenues of the general fund
                            but with borrowing done in the capital
                            projects fund.  The last government fund is
                            the debt service fund.  It is used to hold
                            the money used to pay interest expense and
                            principle on long term debt.
                            <A HREF="C3-glossary.html#defn:GAAP">
                                GAAP
                            </A>
                            does not require this fund.  Often it is the
                            lenders who require a debt service fund to
                            make sure the money is being set aside for
                            payment of interest and principle.  At one
                            time these funds were likely to be called
                            sinking funds.
                        </P>
                        <P>
                            The four subfunds within the basic
                            governmental category (general, special
                            revenue, capital project, debt service) and
                            the
                            <A
                                HREF="C3-glossary.html#defn:account%20groups">
                                account groups
                            </A>
                            can actually be designed to work together to
                            operate and account for the diverse
                            activities of government.  For instance, the
                            capital project funds can be used to account
                            for the construction or purchase of a large
                            building.  This capital project fund might
                            be used to track the money borrowed and
                            spent for the building.  The debt incurred
                            would be recorded in the account group
                            (specifically, the long term debt account
                            group). The long term or
                            <A
                                HREF="C3-glossary.html#defn:fixed%20assets">
                                fixed asset
                            </A>
,                            that is, the building, would be listed in
                            the account groups (namely, the fixed asset
                            account group).  As interest expense and
                            principle came due, money could be
                            transferred from the general fund to the
                            debt service fund to pay the debt.  That
                            year the general fund would, presumably,
                            have to raise enough revenue to transfer to
                            the debt service fund to handle any interest
                            expense and principle due.  All this fund,
                            interfund, and account group accounting is
                            designed for control, and a literal kind of
                            control.  The legislature wants a building;
                            a capital projects fund is set up to track
                            money going in and out to acquire the
                            building.  Lenders want to be sure money is
                            being put away to pay the debt, so a debt
                            service fund is established. Since short
                            term and long term activities are placed in
                            different accounting devices, other funds
                            and account groups must come into play, such
                            as the long term fixed asset group and the
                            long term debt account group.
                        </P>
                    </DD>
                    <DT>
                        <H2>
                            Proprietary Funds
                        </H2>
                    </DT>
                    <DD>
                        The propriety funds are different in purpose
                        from the government funds and designed to be
                        like business financial reporting. However,
                        proprietary funds account for very small part of
                        government activity.  Since they are like
                        business accounting, records are kept on
                        activities regardless of the duration of the
                        activity.  Long term items are not excluded or
                        deemphasized.  The idea is to determine if the
                        fund is breaking even considering all
                        activities.  In other words,
                        <A HREF="C3-glossary.html#defn:matching">
                            matching
                        </A>
                        and
                        <A HREF="C3-glossary.html#defn:accrual">
                            accrual
                        </A>
                        accounting provides a guide for proprietary
                        funds.  For example, revenue would be match
                        against supplies used, cost of products sold,
                        depreciation on fixed assets, and wages earned.
                        Some long term obligations such as pension and
                        other deferred obligations are generally not
                        included but could be.
                        <P>
                            Proprietary funds are becoming more popular
                            as government is pushed toward a competitive
                            model, with at least some of the push coming
                            from those interested in reinventing
                            government. Within the proprietary funds,
                            there two subtypes -- internal service funds
                            (ISF) and enterprise funds (EF).  The ISF is
                            designed for those occasions when one
                            department sells to or services another
                            department in the government.  The ISF helps
                            managers to decide on a fair charge so the
                            fund can break even. In essence it should
                            operate very much like a private firm.  The
                            EF is a government unit or agency that
                            transacts business with firms or people
                            outside the government.  It can seek a
                            profit but the profit is for purposes of
                            replacing plant and innovating not for
                            distributing dividends to shareholders.
                        </P>
                        <P>
                            The
                            <A HREF="C3S2-index.html">
                                financial statements
                            </A>
                            of these proprietary funds would look like
                            those of a business rather than the
                            government type funds just discussed.
                            Unlike government funds, borrowing could not
                            be used in the income statement (often
                            called the statement of revenues, expenses,
                            and changes in retained earnings and
                            contributed equity). Proprietary funds also
                            have a
                            <A
                                HREF="C3-glossary.html#defn:statement%20of%20cash%20flows">
                                statement of cash flow
                            </A>
                            to show the sources of cash (sales to
                            customers, eg) and the use of cash (purchase
                            of raw material, eg), again similar to
                            business.  They have a balance sheet which
                            includes both short term and long term
                            items.
                        </P>
                        <P>
                            Recently,
                            <A
                                HREF="C3-glossary.html#defn:proprietary%20funds">
                                proprietary funds
                            </A>
                            have been criticized for misuse of
                            intergovernmental grants. Some propriety
                            funds have been accused of charging excess
                            overhead to these grants.  For example, a
                            state or local government might have charged
                            20% for overhead in the past when they were
                            charging to local revenues but increased
                            that to more than 20% when they could charge
                            the overhead to intergovernmental grants.
                        </P>
                    </DD>
                    <DT>
                        <H2>
                            Fiduciary Funds
                        </H2>
                    </DT>
                    <DD>
                        The last or third category of funds is
                        fiduciary.  What cuts across these is that
                        someone is holding money for someone or
                        something else.  The government is usually very
                        restricted in what it can do with the money in
                        these funds.  One subtype is a trust funds.
                        Pension funds can be an example.  So too can
                        donations to run libraries, museums, or other
                        facilities. Whatever mandates are written into
                        the trust must be followed by the government.
                        Another subtype of fiduciary is an agency fund.
                        In this case the government might collect taxes
                        for another government, keep an administrative
                        fee for doing the collection, and pass the rest
                        of the money on to the other government.
                        <P>
                            One of the concepts associated with
                            fiduciary funds is expendable and
                            nonexpendable money.  An example is a
                            donation made to sponsor scholarships.  The
                            original donation is nonexpendable.  It is
                            used to earn money via investing.  The
                            earning are expendable and are used to
                            provide the scholarships.
                        </P>
                        <P>
                            Investment pools can also be a fiduciary
                            fund.  In this case one government can
                            invest for many funds or governments.  The
                            assumption is that greater earnings can
                            accrue with the larger pool.  Recently, some
                            problems have resulted when pool managers
                            have invested in financial products with
                            high risk.  With high risk there is the
                            potential for high return but also the
                            potential for significant loss.  The problem
                            is not the pooled fund idea; it's either not
                            understanding the risk or understanding it
                            and taking it.
                        </P>
                    </DD>
                    <DT>
                        <H2>
                            Efficacy of Funds
                        </H2>
                    </DT>
                    <DD>
                        What is gained by all this detail is open to
                        question.  The people most directly interested
                        in a particular
                        <A HREF="C3-glossary.html#defn:funds">
                            fund
                        </A>
                        may be better able to keep track of the
                        activities, but should funds also be a major
                        mode of financial reporting?  Specific
                        activities could be separated for observation
                        and control without funds, or with funds being a
                        secondary reporting device. Additionally, are
                        people outside the government more interested in
                        the government as a whole or in separate funds?
                        If they are interested largely in the
                        <A
                            HREF="C3-glossary.html#defn:financial%20performance">
                            financial performance
                        </A>
                        of the government as a whole, then making funds
                        a central reporting mechanism, to the exclusion
                        of reporting for the entire government, is more
                        of a problem than a solution.
                    </DD>
                    <DT>
                        <H2>
                            Funds and Level of Aggregation
                        </H2>
                    </DT>
                    <DD>
                        Because there can be many specific funds in one
                        fund type, financial statement must aggregate by
                        fund type.  For example, within the special
                        revenue type, a government may have 10 special
                        revenues funds.  It can have one for parks, one
                        for schools, one for road maintenance, and
                        numerous others.  There are three possible
                        levels of aggregation:

                        <MENU>
                            <LI>
                                Combined
                            </LI>
                            <LI>
                                Combining
                            </LI>
                            <LI>
                                Individual
                            </LI>
                        </MENU>
                        <P>
                            All funds of one type presented in summary
                            form are referred to a the combined level.
                            Each financial statement will have a
                            combined level.  Below the combined level is
                            a more detailed level, with all the funds in
                            a specific type.  To differentiate it from
                            the combined, it is called the combining.
                            In the above example, all 10 funds within
                            the special revenue would be presented
                            separately under the title of combining.
                            Finally, for someone who wants to look at
                            each single and separate fund there is the
                            individual fund statements.  The latter, the
                            individual fund presentation, is not
                            necessary given in the CAFR.  Failure to
                            present individual funds seems ironic since
                            the argument for a fund approach is to get a
                            detailed picture.
                        </P>
                        <P>
                            In the CAFR, the top or highest level,
                            called the combined, might look as follows:

                        </P>
<PRE>
  Combined Statement of Revenues, Expenditures, and Changes in Fund
  Balance -- All Government Fund Types for the Year Ended 12/31/19x0

            Government Fund Types
  general fund   special revenue     capital project     debt service
  </PRE>

                        If the special revenue fund has many funds
                        within it, it might look as follows:

<PRE>
  Combining Statement of Revenues, Expenditures, and Changes in Fund
  Balance -- All Special Revenue Funds for the Year Ended 12/31/19x0

      parks      gasoline       lottery
  </PRE>

                        An [actual Combining Statement]&lt;!need to scan
                        this statement &gt; of Revenues, Expenditures,
                        and Changes in Fund Balance -- All Special
                        Revenue Funds is presented for illustrative
                        purposes.
                        <P>
                            Of course, any one of these special revenue
                            funds, such as parks, could be displayed
                            separately.  Separate display of all the
                            special revenue funds would be highly
                            unusual in a CAFR.
                        </P>
                    </DD>
                </DL>
                <HR NOSHADE WIDTH="85%">

                <B>See Also:</B>

                <A HREF="C3S3-aides.html">
                    examples and visual aides
                </A>

                and

                a
                <A HREF="/~jsacco/cgi-bin/gate?C3S3-quiz">
                    quiz
                </A>

            </BODY>
        </HTML>
